The thing that hits me about Metal and the aspect that has me going back for more and more and more is the fact that a good Metal track will capture two intense human experiences almost immediately and follow that with other feelings and emotions that we as human beings experience on a day-to-day level. But what is most intense in my listening experience of Metal is the ability of this music to capture and convey pure unadulturated exuberance, a testosterone-fuelled madness (possibly this is why many many bands become lacklustre as they age. Pagan Altar appear to be an exception) marked by the gallopping riffs of Heavy Metal and the pure speed attacks of Thrash, Death and Black Metal. This encompasses for me absolute hope, immortality and spitting in the face of fate, the hallmarks are "fuck authority", "fuck religion", "fuck the government" etc. In its absolute simplicity this attitude is beautiful; full of youthful exuberance and belief in the self. However and very importantly a good Metal track (or if the band thinks slightly more conceptually, a good Metal album) will have the exuberance tempered by a deep sadness, a dark melancholy. This is what Metal is for me: the perfect combination of youthful high-jinks and knowledge of one's own demise. This is how DarkThrone manage to spit in the face of god on their early output but at the same time keep the listener aware that even the overthrowing of a tyrant does not bring eternal joy, on the contrary, it is an occasion to be surveyed with a misty eye. Do not *Nattasja in eternal sleep*, does not *Freewheel burning*, *Wrathchild*, *Orion* and countless other tracks by such well-known and many less well-known acts teach us this lesson: Good Metal in all its facets is a portal to the inner self, bad Metal is just an insult. The perfect Metal track should have you headbanging and crying at the same time.
9 comments:
I hold similar sentiments on the core meaning of Heavy Metal. I do not write 'Metal' because although the capital letter is sufficiently reverent, there all all sorts of metals. Tinfoil is also a metal, but it is weak. MOLTEN STEEL FASHIONED INTO A SPEAR.
'metal' has been taken over by artists and their audiences that do not seek this awe (or exuberance, as you say) and the accompanied memento-mori melancholy that characterizes Heavy Metal, but instead seek only the sonic bombast of the stylistics of it. 'metal' means, as I understand it, 'extreme music' in general. Heavy Metal means hope, however.
Interesting comment! Yes, I use the term "Metal" (with capital "M") to indicate reverence for this music but for me "Heavy Metal" is a specific part of the entire "Metal" spectrum which includes everything from Rainbow to Carcass to Black Witchery. But I think I disagree that Metal has been taken over by people seduced by mere sonic bombast. There is still plenty of Metal that harks back to the roots, think for example Slough Feg, Devil Lee Rot. Now I know that these bands have members who have been in the scene for 20, 30 years but they are still a "newer" generation from the old guard. There are much younger bands like Dark Forest, Darkest Era or Dead Congregation (for example) who encompass both the exuberance and the melancholy.
I agree, Heavy Metal means hope, the great journey, transcendence of the mortal shell. It is heroic! But all heroes are also in some way tragic figures. I think you can find this in all genres of Metal however. Seek the hero in Morbid Angel's output, in At the Gates', in Mayhem's (anti-hero but still transcending the mortal - I speak of course of the "old" Mayhem) OF COURSE in Bathory's etc. etc.
For the subset of HM called often 'heavy metal', I tend to use 'traditional metal' or '80s metal', 'NWOBHM', 'proto-metal' accordingly, to make the distinction (because that's what most people mean). Heavy Metal, all capped, is the 'mothership', so to say, the eldest root, everything that has glory and tragedy in it (besides the sonic bombast) is filed under that. So, Neurosis, yes, but Pelican, no.
I have no problem to trace the lineage and thematic consistency from Black Sabbath and Judas Priest's formative works to early Mayhem or Morbid Angel as you say. Some people do, but it's clear as day to me.
I will be reading your blog and communicating sometimes, I hope that's alright :)
Helm, that is more than just "all right"; communication is what I was hoping would happen with this blog. I was even considering posting a sub-heading saying something like along those lines but the more organic approach seems to be working out fine also. Might it also be ok for me to use (some of) these conversations in the upcoming issue of my 'zine?
Good piece Piotr and I've enjoyed reading these comments as well. Wish this kind of discussion would be more popular amongst listeners of HM (or music in general). I also hesitate calling stuff that shares these Heavy Metal characterics "metal". That word has suffered from serious deflation for me as you can see people calling everything "loud" from post-hardcore to alternative/hardrock as metal. And then there's Metal that doesn't really feel or act like Heavy Metal I've come to know of. Usually these bands don't even like the term Heavy Metal (sounds too old-ish blah blah) so that tells me a lot about them. Slough Feg IS Heavy Metal for me.
Oh I'm not disagreeing with what Helm and you are saying at all! Heavy Metal as the "mothership" is a really nice way of describing it but for me personally "Heavy Metal" is that what emerged with the NWoBHM. I can't define it better than Judas Priest, Iron Maiden, even Black Sabbath is Heavy Metal, all the mutations of that genre can best be put under the heading of "Metal" with a capital "M". I don't like the term "extreme" music as this can be applied to any genre of music with extreme aesthetics. This includes all genres. Avante-garde classical music that could be defined as essentially an aural assault on the listener could be classified as "extreme" music. But then again, I don't think Carcass are "extreme" so the term has little meaning for me on two levels! The only term that remains for me then is "Metal", pure and simple. I hate the words "True Metal" as they just sound pretentious and stupid and what is "true" anyway? Passion is passion and a musician can't pretend to be passionate as this will come out in his (or her) playing and be audible to the listener so again "Metal" is what I'm left with if I don't want to use "Heavy Metal" do designate other sub-genres such as Death, Black, Doom and whatever else! But that's just my opinion, one I'll stick with until something better and more appropriate presents itself.
Piotr, well it's not that big issue anyway so I think you can get away with it. ;) After all I'm sure that as long as we're having a real conversation you or I will not be misunderstood because whe can choose to elaborate these things if necessary.
And whe = we.. obviously. -.-
Haha of course!
Post a Comment